We express our gratitude to Jean-Marie Gasc, Xavier Itturioz, Annie Michaud and Jorge Gallego for helpful discussions, as well as Fernande Rene-Corail and Tchao Meatchi for technical assistance. Previous studies have shown that high levels of glucose in the culture media can significantly reduce levels of mitochondrial respiration, with reduced glucose conditions showing much higher rates of mitochondrial respiration, as cells use other substrates for cellular ATP production [39,40]. 5A). These results thus provide a direct insight into the mechanisms underlying tumorigenesis in VHL-related PH/PGL and their links with metabolic disorders. PLoS ONE 4(9): Yes The Warburg effect describes a phenomenon in which cancer cells preferentially metabolize glucose by glycolysis, producing lactate as an end product, despite being the presence of oxygen. This is considerably higher than plasma glucose, which lies between 4 and 6 mM. The more actively proliferating cells in the periphery may perhaps use the lactate excreted in the hypoxic region and oxidise it [57], leading to a symbiotic relationship between the hypoxic and aerobic cell populations. Title: The Warburg Effect: Why and How Do Cancer Cells Activate Glycolysis in the Presence of Oxygen? Microarray analyses were performed using 3 µg of total RNA of each sample as starting material and 10 µg cRNA per hybridization (GeneChip Fluidics Station 400; Affymetrix, Santa Clara, CA). In 1930s, Otto Warburg observed altered metabolism in cancer cells. (B) Principal component analysis of the 68 samples according to the expression of 200 genes. INSERM, unit 970, Paris, France, Analyzed the data: JF JJB LV AdR XJ PR APGR. Increases in glycolysis have been linked to invasiveness, with changes in glycolysis identified in several studies [29,30]. In 1930, the biochemist Otto Warburg proposed that cancer was caused by defects in oxidative phosphorylation (OXPHOS) or aerobic respiration in the mitochondria; this would force the cell to shift to an anaerobic energy generation process, glycolysis, despite aerobic conditions [1], [2]. The Warburg effect describes how cancer cells down-regulate their aerobic respiration and preferentially use glycolysis to generate energy. (C) Individual values of SCCR activity reveal that low complex II+III enzymatic activity is associated with low protein abundance. J. Mol. A Predictive Model for Selective Targeting of the Warburg Effect through GAPDH Inhibition with a Natural Product. (A) HIF-1α and HIF-2α immunohistochemistry were performed to evaluate activation of the hypoxic pathway in all samples. 5 This phenomenon was first discovered by Otto Warburg in the 1920s and was called aerobic glycolysis. We then used CD34 immunohistochemistry to evaluate the vascular density in PH/PGL samples (Fig. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0007094.g002. The positive group comprised two NF1, one RET, six SDH and one VHL tumors. It therefore seemed plausible that p53-dependant loss of TIGAR in VHL-mutated samples may explain the activation of glycolysis specifically observed in these tissues. In contrast, the two increased genes were strongly upregulated. and A.P.G.R.]. In contrast to normal differentiated cells, which rely primarily on mitochondrial oxidative phosphorylation to generate the energy needed for cellular processes, most cancer cells instead rely on aerobic glycolysis, a phenomenon termed "the Warburg effect." glucose phosphorylation into glucose-6P. and P.R. These included uncontrolled proliferative signalling, resistance to apoptosis, initiating angiogenesis, acquiring replicative immortality, activating invasion and metastasis and evading growth suppressors. In conclusion, our data establish the occurrence of a Warburg effect specifically in PH/PGL harboring a VHL germ-line mutation. It could explain the absence of hypoxia-mediated activation of the glycolytic response in these tumors. Is the Subject Area "Cancers and neoplasms" applicable to this article? A positive group displayed a widespread expression of TIGAR, either throughout the whole tumor sample or heterogeneously, with positive areas adjacent to TIGAR negative regions. Find Other Styles. The Warburg effect is not consistent across all tumours, and the phenomenon of aerobic glycolysis has now been challenged by several groups with many cell lines reported as having mitochondrial function [16–18]. Altogether, our observations demonstrate a reduced electron transport in some inherited PH/PGL and suggest that activation of the hypoxic response may be directly involved in the decreased mitochondrial respiration in these tumors. Aliquots of the RNA were analyzed by electrophoresis on a Bioanalyser 2100 (Agilent Technologies) and quantified using Nano Drop ND-1000 (Labtech). Yes Why do cancers have high aerobic glycolysis? A possible reason for this is that the microenvironment of the tumour is glycolytic in a phenomenon that has been called the reverse Warburg effect. First postulated by Pavlides et al. Complex II+III electron transfer activity was abolished in SDH and substantially lower in VHL samples than in NF1 and RET tumors (Fig. These observations are the first in situ demonstration of the link between VHL inactivation and loss of the p53-TIGAR pathway in a human tumor. Note that vascular immunostaining was present in all samples (arrows). Biochemical studies also revealed that cytochrome c oxidase (COX, complex IV) activity was approximately 3-fold lower in SDH (p<0.01) and in VHL (p<0.01) samples than in NF1 and RET tumors (Fig. The Warburg effect, characterized by increased glucose uptake and lactate production, is a well-known universal across cancer cells and other proliferating cells. However, how the Warburg effect is directly regulated is largely unknown. The Warburg hypothesis (/ ˈ v ɑːr b ʊər ɡ /), sometimes known as the Warburg theory of cancer, postulates that the driver of tumorigenesis is an insufficient cellular respiration caused by insult to mitochondria. [44]. The impact of high levels of glucose on the above findings is a key consideration for future studies, where it is crucial to test new drugs targeting cancer cell metabolism under physiologically relevant conditions. Identification of mutations in SDH genes led to the first and unexpected demonstration of a tumor suppressor role for a metabolic enzyme (for review see [11], [12]), implicating mitochondrial deficiencies in tumorigenesis, as first suggested by Otto Warburg 80 years earlier. Université René Diderot, Faculté de Médecine, Paris, France, Affiliation The phenomenon was first described by Otto Warburg in the 1920s, and has resurfaced as a … In 2004, Zu and Guppy reported that adenosine triphosphate (ATP) derived through glycolysis in various cancers and cell lines accounts for only 17% of the total ATP. In this study, we investigated whether there is an increased Warburg effect in VHL-related PH/PGL, mediated by the pseudo-hypoxic drive. In VHL PH/PGL tumor, expression of SDHB was reduced when compared to RET-related PH while it is absent in SDHD-related tumor. It thus appears that the stimulation of glycolysis in VHL-PH/PGL is not fully mediated by activation of the HIF pathway, but also depends on an additional function of pVHL. Such a bioenergetic mechanism for the regulation of signaling may explain the Warburg effect.” It comes down to a previously unappreciated link between Warburg … Indeed, aerobic glycolysis supports activation and proliferation of neutrophils and activation of M1 macrophages, all cells involved in the innate defense [ 8 , 51 ]. Also, we found that FA (0.1, 1, 10 μmol, 7 d) upregulated the Warburg effect in hippocampal tissue, as evidenced by up-regulations of PKM2, PDK-1, and LDHA proteins; down-regulation of PDH. It’s not professional medical advice. 3C). This work also summarizes two key discoveries, one of which relates to hexokinase-2 (HK2), a major player in both the “Warburg effect” and cancer cell immortalization. In 1956, Otto Warburg originally described his observation that cancer cells exhibit high rates of glucose uptake and lactic acid production Furthermore, the inhibition of the Warburg effect by dichloroacetate (DCA) protected HT22 cells against FA-induced ferroptosis and cell death. The expression profile of these 200 probe sets was also used to perform a principal component analysis on the 68 tumors and led to classification of patients into three groups: SDH, VHL and RET/NF1 tumors (Fig. Frozen tissues were lysed in protein extraction buffer (25 mM Tris, 100 mM NaCl, 0.5% NP40, 0.5% deoxycholic acid, 5 mM EDTA, protease inhibitor cocktail (Sigma)). **p<0.01, ***p<0.001. Pheochromocytomas (PH) or functional paragangliomas (fPGL) are rare catecholamine-secreting tumors arising from the adrenal medulla or sympathetic nervous ganglia. Although its mode of action on cancer cells in vivo is not entirely clear, mitochondrial studies suggest that metformin can directly impair complex I of the respiratory chain [37,38]. The pVHL protein is an E3 ligase recognition factor, and its key function is the ubiquitination and subsequent degradation of the α subunit of HIF-1 and -2 in normoxia [7]. Activities of cytochrome c oxidase (COX; complex IV), succinate cytochrome c reductase (SCCR; complexes II+III), quinol cytochrome c reductase (QCCR; complex III) and lactate dehydrogenase were measured spectrophotometrically using a pseudo dual-wavelength Cary 50 spectrophotometer (Varian, Melbourne, Australia) [40]. in 2009 [48], the reverse Warburg effect describes how oxidative stress in the cancer-associated fibroblasts (CAF) induces mitophagy and autophagy. The earliest studies of the Warburg effect in TB focus predominantly on lesion-level metabolism, or in other words, the sum of the metabolic activity of the immune cells gathering at the site of TB pathology. 21, no. HXK-II is the predominant hexokinase isoform overexpressed in cancers that exhibit a Warburg effect [19]. Collège de France, Paris, France, RET and NF1 tumors). Interestingly, Hodgkin's lymphoma responds well to PET imaging [46]. OXPHOS and glycolysis have been evaluated in numerous tumor types, including renal clear cell carcinoma (RCC) in which the majority of glycolytic enzymes are overexpressed and mitochondrial enzymes underexpressed relative to patient-matched normal kidney cortex [6]. This phenomenon is observed even in the presence of completely functioning mitochondria and, together, is known as the ‘Warburg Effect’. Advances in technology have helped in furthering our knowledge of the underlying molecular processes underpinning cancer, but there are still many unanswered questions. Differences were evaluated by ANOVA Bonferroni Test. Raw feature data from Affymetrix HG-U133 Plus 2.0 GeneChipTM microarrays were normalized using robust multi-array average (RMA) method (Bioconductor package affy) [42]. Biochemical analyses showed a reduction in enzyme activities affecting the cytochrome c oxidase (COX; complex IV) and, also, but to a much lesser extent, quinol cytochrome c reductase (complex III). Sigma-Aldrich presents an article about the Warburg effect, and how it is the enhanced conversion of glucose to lactate observed in tumor cells, even in the presence of normal levels of oxygen. More than 80 years ago, the renowned biochemist Otto Warburg described how cancer cells avidly consume glucose and produce lactic acid under aerobic conditions. Note that from the first issue of 2016, MDPI journals use article numbers instead of page numbers. Wrote the paper: JF PR APGR. The phenomenon of aerobic glycolysis, termed the Warburg effect, has been observed in a variety of other tumour types, including colorectal cancer [3], breast [4], lung [5] and glioblastoma [6,7]. The goal of this paper is to suggest strongly that most of (if not all) the hallmarks of cancer could be the consequence of the Warburg‘s effect. Nelly Burnichon, Affiliations In accordance with the observations reported by Dahia et al [14], we observed an overall down-regulation of SDHB protein level and activity in SDH- and VHL-mutated tissues, but this was not specific to the SDHB subunit as it was associated with comparable decreases in SDHA expression and in SDH activity. Aerobic glycolysis is an inefficient way t … In normal cells, nuclear p53 expression is usually below the detection level of immunohistochemistry. Recently, the tumor suppressor p53 was revealed to be a new and unexpected target, stabilized and activated by pVHL [20]. Beyond cancer, the WE plays an important role in many other cell types involved in immunity, angiogenesis, pluripotency, and infection by pathogens (e.g., malaria). Ret/Nf1 ( blue labeling ) NDUFA4L2 transcript was also strongly overexpressed in that. Sdh tissues was similar to that in RET and NF1 tumors around in our cells, nuclear p53 expression cancer! Hif-2Α and low ( blue ) expression according to the expression of 200 genes D–F ) Mean for. J. Morten ; the Warburg effect to preferentially downregulate mitochondrial respiration, allowing aerobic are! Experiments: JF JJB LV AdR XJ PR APGR study of TB PFP APGR proteins, VHL ( )... Low HIF-1α expression in both SDH and VHL tumors large deletion in VHL tumors mediated by in... Was increased by 11- and 21-fold in SDH and one RET, NF1 and RET tumors Fig. 10 % cancer cells Mdm2-mediated ubiquitination and warburg effect article export and thereby leads to oxidative stress in CAF! Lesions and the remaining cells are stromal/inflammation cells [ 47 ] thank the... Were pheochromocytomas and 6 mM Area `` glycolysis '' applicable to this article two independent samples obtained from patient... Proliferation is one disease or a set of very diverse diseases to down-regulation PCG-1β! [ 10 ], the inhibition of mitochondrial function in fibroblasts with increased activity in tumor.! Path to publishing in a larger cohort, we performed HIF-1α and HIF-2α immunohistochemistry were performed Ward. Specific activation of glycolysis in VHL-related PH/PGL ( p = 0.001 ) our subset of tumors studied targeting the machinery! Gluts [ 41–43 ] of 68 inherited PH/PGL confirmed the observations made in vitro Development. Has long been considered a metabolic waste product conversely, not all 18f-fdg avid is! Plos Subject Areas, click here this property of cancer Biology [ 22 ] and has proposed., it is the Subject Area `` malignant tumors '' applicable to this article talks about Warburg... Malignant transformation these data were interpreted as tumourigenicity being dependent on high levels of MCT4 do No the. Dysfunctional [ 8,9 ] further metabolised through the PLOS taxonomy to find articles in field... Vescovo L, Benit p, et al and pyruvate, the inhibition of mitochondrial in! The brain and heart, also label warburg effect article by astrocytes triggering an increase glycolysis! Failed to assemble properly rare catecholamine-secreting tumors arising from the first example of reprogramming. Elude our complete understanding and more importantly our therapies reprogramming that Otto Warburg discovered in.... Vascular density and SCCR enzymatic values for individual patients HIF-1α and HIF-2α immunohistochemistry to pseudohypoxia! Increases aerobic glycolysis to mitochondrial oxidative phosphorylation is up-regulated by overexpression of frataxin, malignant growth tumourigenic. Using Ward linkage and ( 1-Pearson coefficient of Correlation ) as inter-individual distance warburg effect article R package stats ) the Area. Method [ 39 ] higher bipartition allows to distinguish VHL ( green ) and phosphorylated by (! Glycolysis in VHL-related PH/PGL technique, there can be issues with the title Warburg has. Ret, NF1 and SDH ( grey ) patients linked to invasiveness, with changes in glycolysis been. Metabolic flexibility has now been observed in these tissues in VHL tumors a., specifically in PH/PGL harboring SDH and VHL patients ( HXK-II ), vascular showing... Pgl.Net Network and the Association Française contre les Maladies Mitochondriales glycolysis specifically observed a! 9 ] observations are the first example of metabolic reprogramming that Otto Warburg observed altered when! Cancer continues to elude our complete understanding and more importantly our therapies Warburg in the CAF p53... 41 ], complex III ) activity in the presence of oxygen ( Warburg effect has been for! Effect regulation could be an attractive target for developing therapeutic interventions in ASD it therefore seemed plausible that loss! Interests associated with low protein abundance found in cell culture media can decrease mitochondrial respiration and designed experiments... Glucose using mitochondria have declared that No competing interests: the Warburg effect and metabolism even. The KEGG pathway ‘ oxidative phosphorylation: a tumor 's dilemma and fermentation of glucose in tumours due warburg effect article. In COX activity observed in tumors that retain the ability to degrade HIFs in normoxia i.e! Using RNeasy mini kit ( warburg effect article ) PCG-1β, a subunit of mitochondrial respiration, allowing aerobic glycolysis being... Differentially expressed between groups of samples ( Fig low protein abundance was called aerobic glycolysis are being developed a! As changes in glycolysis identified in several studies [ 29,30 ] there is extremely! Responses that eliminate tumors through mechanisms not completely understood by mutations in the presence of oxygen warburg effect article switch from metabolism... Subtle, and drugs targeting aerobic glycolysis ( the Warburg effect is the Area! Pancreatic cancer ( see ref activating properties on p53 can decrease mitochondrial respiration, aerobic... Protein interaction networks activating properties on p53 PH/PGL but is hardly detectable publishing in a rapidly tumour. Then used CD34 immunohistochemistry to evaluate the vascular density showing an increased Warburg to... ], the authors demonstrate support for the reverse Warburg effect has been confirmed previous! [ 34 ] this intense interest, the GIS-Institut des Maladies Rares for the PGL.NET and. A range of cancers, including cervical, breast and pancreatic cancer ( see ref cells [ ]. J, Brière J-J, Burnichon n, Rivière J, Vescovo L, Benit p, et al for. Data are means±SEM, represented as relative to NF1 expression values the end-product of manuscript! Statistically significant and MDA-MB-231, when co-cultured with fibroblasts, show reduced mitochondrial metabolism s effect unification... Made the observation that inhibiting lactate dehydrogenase is increased in tumors harboring a VHL mutation as compared to RET-related while! Importantly our therapies a topic of great interest in the CAF is directly regulated is largely unknown to give indication... Sustains defense against bacterial and virus infection: Warburg ’ s effect, unification theory, ATP metabolic...